WHY ARE SOME SAYING TIYANI MAKAMU IS NOT THE RIGHT MISS SOUTH AFRICA?
JOHANNESBURG — Tiyani Makamu had been Miss South Africa for less than an hour when the internet decided her crowning was wrong.
Makamu, 27, from Bronkhorstspruit, was crowned Miss South Africa 2026 on Saturday night at the Sandton Convention Centre, beating 11 finalists including first princess Cwenga Koyana Kotu-Rammopo and second princess Lesego Khumo Nyathela
By Sunday morning she was trending, but not for the reasons the Miss South Africa Organisation wanted. The backlash was not one argument. It was five, crashing into each other at once, and only one was really about her.m
Instead of the famous Mowana crown, the diamond-encrusted crown made by Nungu Diamonds and worn by the last three winners, Makamu was crowned with a plain, angular gold headpiece. Social media compared it to a Burger King paper crown, a Temu purchase, a school project
On Sunday, Nungu Diamonds distanced itself completely: “The crown worn at the 2026 Finale was not designed, crafted or supplied by Nungu Diamonds.”
The company said it had offered Miss SA permission to use the Mowana crown for the finale, even though its sponsorship had not been renewed. The Organisation declined.
Miss SA then admitted it had got it wrong. The headpiece, it said, was only a “temporary ceremonial crown” called Imbokodo, linked to this year’s theme “From Imbokodo to Diamond.” The official crown is still being finalised.
“We acknowledge that this intention should have been communicated more clearly ahead of the finale,” the Organisation said.
For many viewers, the cheap-looking crown made the whole night feel cheap, and Makamu, through no fault of her own, became the face of it.
The second argument was about who didn’t win. Zoalize Janse van Rensburg, 20, a law student and former Miss World South Africa 2024, was a favourite going into the night. She did not make the Top 5.
“Can you explain how did Zoalize not make it to Top 5?” became one of the most repeated comments on Miss SA’s own posts. Others championed Cwenga, or Azana Masango, the singer who made Top 5.
The Organisation, whose judges were led by former Public Protector Prof Thuli Madonsela, said the process was conducted independently and that it “stands firmly behind” Makamu. But when the public’s favourite does not win, “rigged” is always the first word that trends.
The third reason is deeper. Miss South Africa 2026 is a different competition now. Under its new owners, the Organisation has given up its licences for Miss Universe and Miss World. Those titles are now run separately.
Makamu will not go to Miss Universe. She will not go to Miss World. Instead, Miss SA says it is now a “leadership platform” focused on entrepreneurship, advocacy and social impact.
For fans who grew up watching Zozibini Tunzi win Miss Universe in 2019 and Demi-Leigh Nel-Peters win in 2017, that feels like a downgrade. Makamu fits the new brief perfectly.
She is a Group Digital Lead, founder of Hubsela, a platform for entrepreneurs, and her advocacy is youth unemployment and skills development. But many viewers are asking: if she is not going to Miss Universe, is she still really Miss South Africa?
Then there is the argument no one wants to say out loud. Some users said Makamu “doesn’t fit the part,” that she is not glamorous enough, that she looked too serious.
Others defended her fiercely, calling her intelligent, humble and poised, and saying her Q&A and impact speech won the night, not her walk.
It is the oldest pageant trap: when a winner is chosen for brains and purpose, a section of the public still judges her only on beauty.
And then, the most toxic argument. Within hours of her win, some accounts questioned Makamu’s nationality because of her Tsonga surname, claiming she is Zimbabwean or Malawian, not South African.
There is no evidence for that claim. Makamu was born and raised in Bronkhorstspruit, went to Bronkhorstspruit Primary and Cultural High School, and has described herself as a small-town girl from Gauteng.
Makamu is a well-known South African Tsonga surname.
But the attacks show how much the shadow of Chidimma Adetshina still hangs over Miss SA. In 2024, Adetshina, born in Soweto to a Nigerian father and Mozambican-born mother, withdrew from Miss SA amid a vicious campaign questioning her citizenship.
She went on to win Miss Universe Nigeria and finish first runner-up at Miss Universe 2024.
Since then, every Miss SA winner with a name that sounds “foreign” to some ears gets the same treatment. Many South Africans pushed back this weekend: “Can we please stop with the stereotype that being Tsonga automatically makes someone non-South African?”
So, is she the right one? That depends on what you think Miss South Africa is for. If you think it is about a diamond crown, a glamorous walk, and a ticket to Miss Universe, then no.
If you think it is about leadership, entrepreneurship, and a woman who can run a business and a community project, then Makamu is exactly what the new Miss SA says it wants.
What is clear is this: Makamu did not choose the crown. She did not design it. She did not pick the judges. She did not decide to drop Miss Universe.
She just won, on the night, in front of the judges she was given. Whether South Africa lets her reign, or makes her pay for the Organisation’s mistakes, will be the real test of her crown.
