FOUL PLAY OR FOUL WEATHER?: GROWING CHORUS REJECTS OFFICIAL ACCOUNT OF CHIVAYO CRASH AS ASSASSINATION CLAIMS SPREAD

0

FOUL PLAY OR FOUL WEATHER?: GROWING CHORUS REJECTS OFFICIAL ACCOUNT OF CHIVAYO CRASH AS ASSASSINATION CLAIMS SPREAD



HARARE — Reports that the recorder from Wicknell Chivayo’s crashed helicopter has vanished — after authorities first said it was recovered intact — have unleashed a growing chorus of journalists, activists and ordinary Zimbabweans asking the question no one in power wants to answer: Was Chivayo assassinated?



The shift followed Monday’s release of a 14-page preliminary report by the Ministry of Transport’s Air Accidents and Incidents Investigation Department into the September 30 helicopter crash that killed Chivayo, his wife Lucy Muteke, aide Senelisiwe Magagula, Captain Kelvin Tafirei Soda and co-pilot Courage Mutavirwa.



The report attributes the crash to adverse weather — an unintended flight into cloud, followed by controlled flight into terrain — and says there was no evidence of an in-flight break-up or pre-impact explosion.

But it also states that the Cockpit Voice Recorder was not recovered and is presumed destroyed.



That directly contradicts what officials said on October 1, less than 24 hours after the crash, when the Civil Aviation Authority of Zimbabwe (CAAZ) said the flight recorder had been recovered intact and would be central to the investigation.

The report offers no explanation for the reversal.



First thing that threw the spanner into the official line was that six people were initially reported to have been in the fated helicopter but later it was downgraded to five.

Was the mysterious sixth passenger the villain who jump out of the helicopter with a parachute?, some asked.

Journalist Lance Guma was among those who drew a direct conclusion



“Everything now points to the fact that Wicknell Chivayo was assassinated,” Guma wrote.“The Civil Aviation Authority of Zimbabwe (CAAZ) initially made it clear the flight recorder was recovered. The U-turn by the Air Accidents and Incidents Investigation Department of the Ministry of Transport and Infrastructural Development is just bizarre.”



“We can only conclude the person who had the power to make the flight recorder disappear has and had the same power to take down the helicopter. From missing heads to a missing flight recorder, this is a festival of lies from the authorities.



”Guma also linked the crash to factional politics around President Emmerson Mnangagwa’s allies, known as Zvigananda: “In the Zvigananda world ‘people can smile in your face and still wish you harm.’ They have no genuine love for each other, they are united by the desire to loot and get rich.”

Political activist and commentator Rutendo Matinyarare has gone further, alleging Chivayo was “assassinated by powerful elites” and that the missing recorder was deliberate.



Matinyarare, who offered no documentary evidence for the claim, warned that further targeted actions could not be ruled out if political and factional tensions did not subside.

His post, widely shared on Facebook, has drawn thousands of comments, many echoing the assassination theory and citing the recorder’s disappearance as proof of a cover-up.



Investigative journalist Hopewell Chin’ono shared pages from the preliminary report highlighting the recorder section, triggering hundreds of comments questioning how a device designed to survive extreme impact and fire could vanish without trace.

Opposition politician Fadzayi Mahere also questioned the disappearance, asking: “How can the black box disappear?”



A NewsHawks critical analysis of the report said the contradictions had “undermined public confidence in the official narrative, while thickening the plot of foul play.



”The analysis noted that black boxes are engineered with crash-survivable memory units designed to withstand up to 3,400 Gs and jet-fuel fires exceeding 1,100°C, and said claiming a certified recorder completely disintegrated without leaving a trace of its hardened casing “stretches aviation engineering norms.”



It also flagged the report’s late release — more than two weeks past its statutory 30-day deadline — and the unresolved forensic question of why Chivayo and Muteke were buried on October 8 without their heads, as forensic teams failed to locate cranial remains.

Deepening the mystery is the statement attributed to ITC Minister, Tatenda Mavetera who privately messaged or told ZANU-PF-aligned influencer/propagandist C.H. (Cleopas) Mukungunugwa that the helicopter carrying Wicknell Chivayo “blew up in the air”.



On Facebook, Instagram and X, the dominant reaction has not been acceptance of the weather explanation, but disbelief.

Commenters on posts by CITE, ZimCelebs and Crime Watch Zimbabwe repeatedly cite the same three points: the recorder was first said to be found intact, then said to be missing; the victims’ heads were not recovered;“Voice recorder not found — ndopane nyaya yese,” one commenter wrote, meaning “that is the whole issue.”



Another wrote: “The guy was murdered end of story, becoz zvese zvaivepo never mix up from day 1.”

Others argue the crash could still have been weather-related, or that bad weather combined with foul play cannot be ruled out.

A minority have urged the public to wait for the final report.



The preliminary report says the Bell 430, registration Z-PED, departed Gandami Village at around 4:20 p.m. alongside a Bell 407, entered thick fog, low clouds and poor visibility, and its last radio transmission indicated it had entered another cloud layer and had not emerged.



Investigators found the aircraft remained intact until impact, then disintegrated across a 170-by-75-metre debris field as spilled fuel ignited. They described the crash as non-survivable.

Transport officials have stressed the findings remain preliminary.

A final report will be issued once all evidence is examined.



No official finding of foul play has been made, or why the alleged foul play coincided with foul weather.



What has grown is not proof, but a shared conclusion among a widening circle of critics: that the gap between what officials first announced and what they are now saying has made the official account impossible for many Zimbabweans to accept.

Source: Mopani News

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here