policy Failure caused Zambia’s Food Crisis
BERNADETTE MUSHINGE AND GRIEVE CHELWA
This past,Thursday, President Hakainde Hichilema addressed the nation and declared a National Disaster in light of a prolonged dry spell that will affect this year’s agriculture output, especially that of maize which is Zambia’s staple food.
In his address, the president appealed for help “calling upon [Zambia’s] partners, local and international, to avail food and other support that they may have, in order to provide the needed relief.”
This is the first time in a long time that the country has declared a national disaster related to food leaving many to wonder what might have gone wrong.
To be sure, President Hichilema is correct in his assertion that the El Niño-induced dry spell will greatly affect this year’s maize production.
But where he is wrong is in asserting that the dry spell alone explains the hunger crisis that the country will face this year.
As we show below, the looming hunger crisis, which sparked last Thursday’s desperate plea for help, was caused by policy failure on the part of the Zambian government whose chief executive is Hichilema himself.
The story of Zambia’s maize production over the last 20 years or so has been nothing short of a miracle.
Between 2001 and 2021, the country more than tripled its maize output.
According to data from Zambia’s Ministry of Agriculture as reported by FAOSTAT, total maize production in 2001 stood at just under 1 million metric tonnes (MT).
By 2021, that number had grown to 3.62 million MT making that year’s output the biggest in the country’s history.
As is always the case, miracles of this scale (just like disasters) have much to do with government policy. In 2002, the Zambian government, then under the leadership of Levy Mwanawasa, introduced the Farm Input Support Programme (FISP) that was to provide large-scale subsidized farm inputs mainly to peasant farmers. It is FISP that explains Zambia’s maize miracle.
It is FISP that has guaranteed Zambia’s food security in spite of droughts in the intervening years. (Incidentally, and unsurprisingly, the IMF has consistently tried to place FISP on the chopping block. They may very well succeed.
It is this record breaking maize harvest of 2021 that Hichilema’s government inherited after winning the August 2021 presidential elections. In addition, the new government inherited maize stock of 841,000 MT that was brought forward from the previous year (2020) as surplus. Therefore, the total maize supply in the year Hichilema won his first election was 4.5 million MT (the total of 3.62 million MT and 841,000 MT)!
This was more than sufficient for 2021’s consumption given that total consumption (including animal feed and exports) was estimated at 3 million MT, leaving a record surplus of 1.5 million MT to be brought forward into 2022 (the following year).
Immediately, Hichilema’s government began to eye 2021’s surplus as a potential source of export revenues, likely urged on by the likes of the IMF who encouraged government to “take advantage of market opportunities presented by neighbouring countries”.
The new government then began to make policy changes that would increase Zambia’s maize exports.
In their first budget speech delivered in October 2021, barely two months into their administration, the new Minister of Finance scrapped the 10% tax on maize exports that had been in effect since 2017, a tax that likely prevented a hunger crisis in 2019 given that year’s drought.
Parallel to this was a huge public relations effort whose objective was to justify the new policy of encouraging an increase in maize exports (Zambian TikTok user @rooney0303 in a video that has gone viral has compiled some of the statements from various government ministers that were given to justify the policy).
Unsurprisingly, this new policy substantially increased maize exports. Data compiled from the Ministry of Agriculture/Zambia Statistics Agency shows that the volume of maize exports increased by at least 75% from 2021 to 2022!
Data from the Bank of Zambia shows the monetary value of maize export earnings increased from US$49 million in 2021 to US$109 million in 2022, an increase of 122% in a single year!
Much of Zambia’s maize is exported to countries in the region. One such country is Kenya where data from the Kenya Bureau of Statistics shows that maize imports from Zambia increased in value by a whopping 371% in 2022, another incredible number in a single year. (These patterns were likely repeated in other destination countries (DR Congo, Tanzania, etc…) where data is not readily available as is the case with Kenya).
The scale of the policy failure becomes even more evident when one considers that this unprecedented increase in maize exports took place in a year when the country registered one of the biggest declines in maize production.
As earlier stated, 2021 registered record production of 3.62 million MT.
But in 2022 production dropped by close to a million metric tonnes to 2.7 million MT on the back of poor rainfall and the haphazard handling of fertilizer distribution in the 2021/22 farming season, a farming season presided over by Hichilema’s new government.
Huge exports on the one hand and declining production on the other bequeathed to 2023 a smaller surplus than was bequeathed to 2022.
We do not as yet have a complete statistical picture of what took place in 2023 but it is quite clear from statements made by government officials that maize exports might have continued unabated in that year as well.
The sum total of the evidence presented here paints a picture of policy failure as being at the heart of the food disaster declared by the president last Thursday. El Niño has made dire what was already a bad situation.
Bernadette Mwansa Mushinge is an independent researcher with an MSc in Agricultural Sciences from Stellenbosch University. She can be reached at bernadettemushinge@gmail.com.
Grieve Chelwa is Associate Professor of Political Economy at The Africa Institute and non-resident Senior Fellow at Tricontinental: Institute for Social Research.
Mr. inflation is back again. First hiding behind the name of a John Hopkins Professor now coming to lecture us after failing to explain how Denny Kalyelye was wrong in his computation of inflation.
Its so much easier to quietly do research and let peer reviewed journals let your work speak for you….kikikiki
Great analysis Prof. Chelwa and madam Mushinge. You are great patriots. May God continue to richly bless you with wisdom.
Amen. We should call a spade a space. A conman, we should call a conman.
He man has sold off all our maize reserves for a rusted piece of nickel, yet some people are praising his foolishness, greed, and total incompetence.
Vote wisely in 2026.
Ba Dr waku matero, ATI great analysis sooo! You think by now nobody knows how pfidiots present things? Let me show you pfidiots always mix absolute figures with percentages then include varying periods and think you’re you’re clever. Only amongst your fellow stupid pfidiots!¡!!
We know from our own country-wide research that FISP had numerous challenges particularly with DACOs, PACOs and camp officers charged with the implementation of the scheme and inadequate agricultural extension services. But what was needed was not to try and do away with it but solve the inherent problems of it to reduce on inefficiencies of it, corruption by civil servants charged with the running of the scheme and improve on farmer knowledge and skills. That would have helped further increase agricultural production.
The real disaster@
Leadership Disaster.
This is the greatest enemy if this country.
A pompous, know it all, monotone direction less leadership where consultation with the past events is snubbed, wanting to champion a new cause as if to say all that went before him were ignorant,
We are watching him. The damage he has caused to this country is unimaginable.
Great analysis backed by empirical and factual data.
In times of good harvests, much of the crop would go to waste if it’s not exported to create storage room for freshly-harvested grain. That’s because Zambia lacks sufficient storage space to keep grain safe beyond two years. Keeping grain under tarpaulins is expensive and prone to theft. The solution is to build bulk grain storage bins made of steel and the Food Reserve Agency doesn’t have them. The old-fashioned grain silos inherited from UNIP government are all out of service.
This is our problem. We don’t engage in patriotic & problem solving discourse. Instead we engage in insults. What are we going to reap from insults? I see nothing wrong with Chelwa and Mushinge article. It goes far back as 2001and is grounded in numbers. Numbers don’t lie unless they are cooked. I would encourage the authors to extrapolate to 2030 or even 2040 and most importantly state what NEEDS TO BE DONE to get into surplus position and spin off industries from such growth. The two years covered post 2021 are too short to form a basis for policy formulation. This short sightedness is a product of of multi party system. Politicians dont think beyond the 5 year election cycle. This drought is a crisis & yet it presents an opportunity to actualize the much talked about irrigation potential & abundant water bodies that zambia has. Solar power as well. I am tired of talking about POTENTIAL. I would like to see ACTION. Chelwa and Mushinge as experts in this field, please write a follow up article with suggestions on the way forward
To Chelwa & Mushinge. When you derive
opinions such as this; (Incidentally, and unsurprisingly, the IMF has consistently tried to place FISP on the chopping block. They may very well succeed). Make citations as academics you should know this. Suffice to say I have misgivings about this never ending subsidy of small scale and emerging farmers that were supposed to graduate into commercial farmers decades ago? What’s should we do? Should we continue to underpin our food security on these hardworking but ineffecient and vulnerable ( to climate and subsidies) farmers? We cannot abandon them, they are are our people and we can trace our roots from those villages. I am not schooled in agriculture but my gut feeling is that less capital intensive cassava, millet, sorghum etc is the answer for our rural folks. It’s a fallacy to dream that they can be weaned off subsidies and be as productive as commercial farmers after 60 years of subsidies after subsidies. Bear in mind that our population is growing and urbanising. Yes the western world pay subsidies to its farmers. For example the USA embargo on Cuba is now more about protecting the American beetroot and tobacco farmers from Cuban sugar, cigarettes/cigars that would roll out of cuba and kill American farmers if the embargo was lifted. Your thoughts please.
El nino , yes Hichilema can blame that for the country wide hunger that has engulfed the entire country, but as stated in the article above poor government policies for past 2 years have also contributed to this! And us christians in this christian country called Zambia, also hope that the Upnd leadership will this year find time to observe the national day of prayer which falls on October 18, every year! Upnd top leadership has avoided attending the national day of prayer since they came into power! As for last year bali ponta no ku ponta about the national day of prayer! Lesa filya ta fwaya! Lesa ala panika abantu able musula! God punishes in various ways, like now it’s through El Nino! So Lesa alinga uku chindika nangu niwebo King! After all even kings die!