US RAISES NATO MEMBERSHIP IN EXCHANGE FOR A UKRAINIAN WITHDRAWAL FROM DONBAS
For the first time, American negotiators have asked whether Ukraine would withdraw from the Ukrainian-held part of Donbas if the country were admitted to NATO, President Volodymyr Zelenskyy revealed.
This is not yet a formal offer. There is no agreed security package, NATO invitation or guarantee that every member of the Alliance would approve Ukraine’s accession. Zelenskyy described it as a question raised during negotiations—one Ukraine cannot answer on the basis of vague promises.
“I have repeatedly said: Ukraine does not retreat and does not give its land to terrorists,” the president told journalists. If Washington and the other NATO allies eventually present a concrete and credible proposal, Zelenskyy said he would put the question before Ukrainian society rather than make such a historic decision alone.
The package under discussion would reportedly include NATO and EU security guarantees, the preservation of a large and heavily armed Ukrainian military, long-term financial support and a properly funded reconstruction plan. None of those elements has yet been converted into a binding proposal.
Withdrawing from the remaining Ukrainian-held Donbas would not mean surrendering one interchangeable piece of territory. It would mean abandoning the Sloviansk–Kramatorsk–Druzhkivka–Kostiantynivka fortress belt: a layered system of cities, defensive positions, logistics routes and fortifications that Ukraine has strengthened over many years.
Russia is currently paying an extraordinary price attempting to approach and penetrate these defenses. Ukrainian daily estimates of Russian personnel losses have repeatedly exceeded 2,000 killed and wounded. Those figures cannot be independently confirmed in real time, but they illustrate the scale of the fighting. Handing over the fortress belt would allow Moscow to obtain at a negotiating table what its army has been unable to seize without devastating losses.
NATO membership could provide Ukraine with its strongest possible long-term protection—but only if it were real, binding and supported by every ally. Ukraine cannot exchange defensible ground for another Budapest Memorandum written in stronger language. The exact borders covered by any collective-defense guarantee, the timing of accession and what happens before membership takes effect would all be decisive.
Zelenskyy also addressed the continuing Starshield disruptions. SpaceX told Ukraine’s Defense Ministry that it had imposed no restrictions and described the problem as technical. Ukraine, however, says its forces have detected widespread speed restrictions for five consecutive days, including limitations affecting drone-interception operations. The cause therefore remains unresolved, and Kyiv is continuing its tests.
The remaining Donbas is not merely land on a map. It is fortified ground purchased with years of preparation and Ukrainian blood. Any proposal requiring its abandonment must offer more than political language—it must provide security strong enough to ensure that Russia can never use the surrendered territory as the starting point for its next invasion.
