ZAMBIA’S BUDGET WOULD BE US$239 BILLION UNDER THE BAHAMAS REVENUE MODEL: A COUNTRY 54 TIMES SMALLER IN LAND AREA AND POPULATION, WITH ZERO PAYE, EXPOSES THE INTELLECTUAL EXHAUSTION OF OUR FISCAL ORTHODOXY

0

ZAMBIA’S BUDGET WOULD BE US$239 BILLION UNDER THE BAHAMAS REVENUE MODEL: A COUNTRY 54 TIMES SMALLER IN LAND AREA AND POPULATION, WITH ZERO PAYE, EXPOSES THE INTELLECTUAL EXHAUSTION OF OUR FISCAL ORTHODOXY



I invite the People’s Assembly to interrogate the economic philosophy underpinning Zambia’s 2027 National Budget. At a time of declining household purchasing power, constrained domestic capital formation and mounting costs of production, the Government proposes additional taxation on employment income, consumption and financial transactions.



This fiscal disposition is fundamentally at variance with the growth agenda so frequently proclaimed in official speeches. The persistent escalation of taxation upon productive activity, household incomes and commercial transactions undermines the very economic expansion the Government professes to pursue. Must a resource rich nation continually intensify taxation upon its citizens, or can it reorganise its productive economy to mobilise substantially greater public revenue?



The Bahamas is an island nation of approximately 403,000 inhabitants, occupying a total surface area of merely 13,880 square kilometres, compared with Zambia’s 752,618 square kilometres. The geographical and demographic comparison is intellectually arresting. Zambia is approximately 54 times larger than The Bahamas in surface area, and its population is also approximately 54 times greater. On the strength of these two dimensions alone, one would reasonably expect Zambia to command an economy and public revenue capacity commensurate with its vastly superior territorial and demographic endowments.



If Zambia generated government revenue at the same rate per inhabitant as The Bahamas, its annual revenue would approach US$239 billion, equivalent to approximately K4.8 trillion. The Bahamas projects US$4.4 billion in government revenue for 2026/27, maintains currency parity with the United States dollar and imposes no personal income tax. Zambia, endowed with immense mineral wealth, fertile agricultural land, abundant water resources and substantial energy potential, continues to intensify taxation upon its citizens. A nation approximately 54 times larger in both land area and population ought to possess the productive ambition, institutional ingenuity and economic organisation to become substantially wealthier.



Members of the People’s Assembly, reflect upon the implications of this fiscal comparison! This is only a population scaled benchmark. It nevertheless raises important questions about fiscal productivity, institutional efficiency and the economic utilisation of national resources. Zambia possesses copper, cobalt, gold, emeralds, agricultural land, water and energy potential. Our developmental imperative is to convert these endowments into industrial production, domestic beneficiation, profitable public assets and diversified revenue streams.



When I presented the UPP’s proposed K500 billion Alternative National Budget for 2027, some questioned its feasibility because Zambia’s projected GDP was approximately K1 trillion. Their objection presumed that public expenditure approaching 50% of GDP was inherently impermissible. Such a textbook mentality is wrong. Finland’s general government expenditure reached 57.5% of GDP in 2024, France recorded 57.2% and Austria 56.3%. Guyana’s national budget more than doubled between 2022 and 2024. Therefore, it is possible to double the national budget in a short space of time.



These comparisons demonstrate that fiscal ratios are not immutable economic ceilings. The decisive considerations are sovereign revenue capacity, expenditure productivity, financing sustainability and the institutional competence to transform resources into national wealth. The intellectual exhaustion of inherited fiscal orthodoxy becomes apparent when existing economic constraints are mistaken for permanent limits upon productive possibility. As you all know, Zambia’s 2027 Budget proposes increasing VAT from 16% to 16.5%, introducing a top marginal PAYE rate of 39.5% on monthly earnings above K37,000, and raising mobile money levies. These measures warrant examination through the principles of tax incidence, distributive equity and household welfare.



The People’s Assembly must understand that taxation extends beyond salaried workers. A villager purchasing taxable goods contributes to public revenue. A minibus passenger bears taxes incorporated into transport costs. A market trader encounters taxation through supplies and commercial transactions. The statutory taxpayer and the ultimate bearer of taxation are not necessarily the same person.



The UPP proposes the complete abolition of PAYE over three years, accompanied by alternative revenue mobilisation. The 2027 Budget projects approximately K35.37 billion in PAYE receipts. Replacing this revenue requires mineral rent optimisation, profitable public enterprises, commercialisation of state assets, industrial diversification and the systematic elimination of fiscal leakages.



Our economic proposition is grounded in domestic capital formation. Greater disposable income can strengthen household savings, investment and purchasing power. When accompanied by productive industrial capacity, this can stimulate manufacturing, employment and wider economic activity. Fiscal restructuring must therefore proceed alongside affordable productive credit, energy security and industrial competitiveness.



Zambia must move beyond the predominantly extractive organisation of its mineral economy. Copper must support electrical manufacturing and engineering industries. Agriculture must sustain processing, storage, packaging and export enterprises. All 116 districts must progressively become centres of productive specialisation and capital accumulation.



The delayed payment of maize farmers by the Food Reserve Agency further demonstrates the importance of fiscal execution. Outstanding obligations of approximately K14.6 billion constrain agricultural working capital, disrupt production cycles and transmit liquidity shortages throughout rural economies. Public financial management must facilitate production rather than immobilise the resources of productive citizens.



The Bahamas illustrates revenue mobilisation without personal income tax. Guyana demonstrates accelerated fiscal expansion through resource development. Finland, France and Austria show that government expenditure exceeding half of GDP is neither unprecedented nor economically prohibited. Zambia requires a fiscal architecture suited to its productive endowments, institutional capabilities and developmental aspirations. The UPP’s K500 billion Alternative Budget represents a proposal for industrial expansion, improved sovereign revenue mobilisation, greater household income retention and disciplined public investment.



The continued poverty of a resource rich nation demands an examination of its productive institutions, fiscal priorities and distribution of economic opportunity. Zambia’s prosperity must be measured by the wealth retained by its citizens, the industries established upon its resources and the economic advancement of its 116 districts. Our greatest limitation must never become the poverty of our economic imagination.

Saviour Chishimba
(Yehudah Ben David)
President
THE PEOPLE’S ASSEMBLY

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here