Outcry Over Prolonged Detention of Brothers Without Charge: A Challenge to Zambia’s Democratic Principles
In a case sparking outrage across Zambia, Elijah and Ernest, two young brothers from Kalulushi, have been held in police custody since October 3, 2024, without charge or access to bail. Their alleged “crime”? Recording a TikTok video urging President Hakainde Hichilema to deliver on his campaign promises or consider stepping down.
This prolonged detention, in violation of Zambia’s constitutional right to be charged or released within 48 hours, has raised alarm among citizens, civil society, and human rights organizations. Critics argue it highlights a troubling pattern of stifling dissent in a nation that prides itself on democracy and free expression.
The brothers were apprehended in Kalulushi and transported to Lusaka, where they remain in custody. Despite multiple appeals to the police, civil society groups, and legal bodies such as the Law Association of Zambia (LAZ), efforts to secure their release or ensure they face formal charges have reportedly been ignored.
The Zambia We Want (ZWW), a civic organization advocating for democracy, issued a scathing statement accusing the United Party for National Development (UPND) government of weaponizing the police to silence critics. “This cannot be right and is totally unacceptable behavior in a constitutional democracy,” stated Muhabi Lungu, interim spokesperson for ZWW.
The ZWW argues that this case is not isolated. Over the past three months, at least five other individuals, including outspoken critics like Jason Mwanza and Raphael Nakachinda, have faced similar treatment for expressing dissenting views about the government.
“These incidents suggest a systematic attempt to intimidate and silence voices questioning the presidency or the ruling party,” said Lungu.
Critics have likened the police’s actions to those of authoritarian regimes, with some warning of the erosion of democratic principles Zambia has worked hard to uphold since the advent of multiparty democracy in 1991.
The UPND government, which campaigned on a platform of transparency, justice, and human rights, is now facing scrutiny over its perceived backsliding on these commitments. Observers have noted an increase in arrests of citizens for social media posts, speeches, or actions deemed critical of the presidency.
Many are questioning the legal basis for such actions, particularly after the removal of the defamation of the president law, which previously criminalized statements deemed insulting to the head of state.
“If this law is truly repealed, why are citizens being detained for simply expressing their opinions?” asked a lawyer representing one of the detained individuals.
As Zambia grapples with these issues, the nation finds itself at a crossroads. Will it honor its democratic ideals and the rule of law, or will it slide into a culture of fear and repression?
For now, the fate of Elijah and Ernest remains uncertain, but their case serves as a reminder that the price of democracy is eternal vigilance. The Zambian people, it seems, are ready to demand answers.
KUMWESU DEC 2, 2024
I do not think Hakainde is aware of these detentions. He would never approve such draconian methods to oppress innocent citizens. Hakainde is a true advocate of freedom of speech, and would never allow any citizen to be detained without charge for over 24 hours. Since he got elected, no one has been arrested on flimsy charges, or incarcerated without trial for more than 48 hours. We are so lucky to have such a selfless leader.
Vote wisely in 2026.